To obtain the Strange Friends Trophy in Voice of Cards: The Forsaken Maiden, you must first complete The Tale of the Ivory Maiden then leave the North Isle. We discovered the East Isle then chose to return to Alabaster City. When you’re ready to return to the North Isle, enter Alabaster City and speak with the familiar face near the Armorer. Afterwards, travel north to the Palace to spot another familiar face nearby. Interact with her to trigger the trophy.