To obtain the Starla’s Safe Key needed for the Starla’s Award Show Safe in Dead Island 2, travel to the Old Dynasty Theatre set in Hollywood Boulevard.
Once there, you’ll find Starla Taylor-Moore. Take her down then loot the Starla’s Safe Key from where she falls.
Now that you have the key, head to the lockbox underneath the easternmost seating and unlock Starla’s Award Show Safe. As a reward, you’ll receive the Smashing Composite Sledgehammer.
