Welcome to NGB and our The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered walkthrough for the May the Best Thief Win quest! This guide will cover everything you need to know to easily complete this quest, including how to start the mission and the steps you will need to take to finish it.
If you need help with a specific objective, please refer to our Quick Links section to quickly find the information you need!
Quick Links
How to Start the May the Best Thief Win Quest
You’ll begin the May the Best Thief Win quest in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered automatically after completing the Finding the Thieves Guild quest.
May the Best Thief Win Walkthrough
As instructed by Armand Christophe, your task is to steal the diary of Amantius Allectus before Methredhel and Amusei and bring it back to him. You’ll need to complete this task without killing either Amantius or any of your competitors.
Steal Amantius Allectus’ Dairy
In this section, you can also find a beggar to speak with, but it will waste time. The one we used was sleeping in an alley behind Marana Rian’s House in the northwestern part of the area. Ask them about Amantius Allectus and offer to pay them five coins. They should then tell you that Amantius lives in the Temple district on the far east side. You’ll also learn that he is an early riser and usually is up by sunrise.

Enter the Temple District from the Waterfront, then take a right and follow the path along the alley and wall to the end. You’ll then want to take a left and keep going until you reach the part where the main path runs through the alley. The last house on the left will be Amantius’.

You’ll need to pick the lock to head inside. Once you do, look to the right of the living room to find a weird-looking desk against the wall. Interact with it to retrieve the diary. If you are not quick, then Methredhel will beat you to the diary. If that happens, you’ll need to steal the diary from her without killing her. She has a house in the Waterfront, near where you met Armand, that she can appear in.

Deliver the Diary to Armand Chrisophe
Now that you have the diary, return to Armand in the Waterfront area and speak with him. Choose the “Thieves Guild Test” option to hand it over, thus earning you a place in the Thieves Guild! This will complete the May the Best Thief Win quest, while also starting the Independent Thievery quest.
Oblivion Remastered: Guides, Tips, and Walkthroughs
Looking for more of The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered content? Use the links below to keep exploring our guides:
- Main Page: Check out our The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered hub page for all our latest content!
- Official Site: Stay up to date with the latest Oblivion Remastered news on the official website.

