A Collection of Rogues Collectible Quest – The Outer Worlds 2

The Outer Worlds 2 Logo

Welcome to NGB and our walkthrough for A Collection of Rogues quest in The Outer Worlds 2. This collectible quest tasks you with tracking down Pitchball and Tossball cards scattered across the colonies. Our guide will walk you through all the objectives, highlight the best strategies, and make sure you don’t miss any rewards.

Quick Links

A Collection of Rogues Collectible Quest Guide

How to Start the A Collection of Rogues Collectible Quest

The Outer Worlds 2 A Collection of Rogues

To start the A Collection of Rogues collectible quest, you’ll need to travel to Free Market Station and head for The 2nd Choice saloon. Once inside, go upstairs and speak with Fionna F. Walker.

A Collection of Rogues The Outer Worlds 2

She will challenge you to a battle. Do you know what that means? It’s time to D-D-Duel! With your tossball and pitchball cards!

A Collection of Rogues Walkthrough

Find Cards

To battle Fionna F Walker, the professional collector, you’ll need to amass 15 sports cards to give her a run for her money.

Pitchball Card: Alex Wilson
Pitchball Card: Alex Wilson

Paradise Island – This card can be found tacked on the wall of Fairfield Saloon.

Pitchball Card: Alex Wilson
Pitchball Card: Chris Stanick
The Outer Worlds 2 Ascent in the Howling Tower

Paradise Island – On Deck 4 of the Skycutter Tower, you’ll find this card on the rolly table on the southern side of the level.

Pitchball Card: Chris Stanick
Pitchball Card: Gaby Gonzalez
Pitchball Card: Gaby Gonzalez

Paradise Island – This card can be found in the building just north of The Bridge of the Reverent.

Pitchball Card: Gaby Gonzalez
Pitchball Card: Josephus Fielder

Paradise Island – During the In Pursuit of Purloined Propaganda quest, you will receive this card as a reward from Redactor Quesnel for turning in five issues of the Science Adventures Quarterly periodicals.

Pitchball Card: Kelvin Nakamura
Pitchball Card: Kelvin Nakamura

Paradise Island – This card can be found in the building just north of the Bridge of the Reverent.

Pitchball Card: Kelvin Nakamura
Pitchball Card: Kevin Anderson
Pitchball Card: Kevin Anderson

Golden Ridge – This pitchball card can be found inside a tent on the western side of Golden Ridge.

Pitchball Card: Kevin Anderson
Pitchball Card: Matthew Zimmerman
Pitchball Card: Matthew Zimmerman

Golden Ridge – This sports card can be found on the southwestern side of Matriarch’s Mercy in a train car. To enter the car, you will need to have completed the Schemes of the Secret Smugglers side quest!

Pitchball Card: Matthew Zimmerman
Pitchball Card: Nathan Lawter

You can obtain this card during the A Cause Worth Killing For main quest. If you went the Security Ops Route, you can find this card on the door of an open locker.

the outer worlds 2 Pitchball card nathan lawter

If you went the Central Dispatch route, you can find this card on the door of an open locker with the stun baton.

Pitchball Card The Outer Worlds 2
Pitchball Card: Roozbeh Madanipour
Pitchball Card: Roozbeh Madanipour

Paradise Island – This pitchball card can be found on a corpse just east of the Vox Relay Station.

Pitchball Card: Roozbeh Madanipour
Pitchball Card: Sahil Shah
Pitchball Card: Sahil Shah

Paradise Island – During the Lab That Shouted Incoherently and Often quest, you’ll find this card in the rafters next to a hose.

Pitchball Card: Sahil Shah
Pitchball Card: Tony Blackwell

Free Market Station – This card can be found behind Fionna, next to the liquor.

Pitchball Card: Tony Blackwell
Pitchball Card: Yilan Tang

Free Market Station – This card can be found on a long narrow table behind a circle of chairs near Doc Halvorsen.

Pitchball Card: Yilan Tang
Tossball Card – Anthony Rogers
Tossball Card - Anthony Rogers

Paradise Island – To find this tossball card, loot the container on the platform with the Westport Potable Water Supply!

The Outer Worlds 2 Tossball Card
Tossball Card: Daniel Cabuco
Tossball Card: Daniel Cabuco

Paradise Island – During the Better Than Nature quest, you can find this tossball card on the ground next to a severed arm. It will be on a high ledge in the area where you fight the Raptidon Matriarch.

Tossball Card: Daniel Cabuco
Tossball Card: Hannah Kennedy
Tossball Card: Hannah Kennedy

Golden Ridge – At Alexandra Station by the launchpad, open the locked door using Lockpick 5 and one Mag-Pick to find a chest inside. Open this chest to loot the tossball card.

Tossball Card: Hannah Kennedy
Tossball Card: Shaina Grade
Tossball Card: Shaina Grade

Paradise Island – This tossball card can be found next to the terminal in a house on the northwestern side of Westport.

Tossball Card: Shaina Grade
Tossball Card: Simon Smith
Tossball Card: Simon Smith

Golden Ridge: This card can be found at the Guardian Estates. It will be to the left of the largest building near the cliff.

Tossball Card: Simon Smith

Return to the Card Collector

Once you have the 15 tossball and pitchball cards, return to Fionna and speak with her to begin the duel! After a short pause, you’ll be declared the winner, completing the quest! Your prize is that she will now let you purchase some unique item through her shop.

To access it, follow her around the corner where she’ll unlock a door and head inside. Go in after her and speak with Fionna to check out her wares.

Looking for more The Outer Worlds 2 content? Use the links below to keep exploring our guides:

Scroll to Top